Logo stylisé de Xnotes, lettre X blanche sur fond bleu

On You Maniac and why the series is so important to me


First of all, 10/10 rating and experience to me. Hands down. Easily one of the best series in BL-scene in the last few years (no, I'm not joking). I can't really express how grateful I am to be able to watch this in real-time, just when I was craving for something that could move me in the way that other series couldn't. I'm so, so, so glad that WilliamEst chose/accepted to star in this series. And just like what they said about the challenges and what they aimed, them playing DeanMoth proved me and everyone that they're indeed no joke when it comes to their acting work.


Now, onto the series itself. I gotta be honest that I didn't expect so much when the trailer got released because it highlighted the broader trope of "two red flags meeting each other", which could definitely be defined in so many ways - why emphasising red flag? Isn't everyone a red flag in at least one aspect in their life? I'm not much a fan of trope-ey series, because sometimes they tend to feel like the world is just a small, glossy bubble and it's not real. But then came episode 1 and the rest is history.


You Maniac, for me, is one for the books. It's so different from any series in any way, in a good way, in the best way possible. The story is very grounded and feels very real: there are definitely Deans and Moths out there, finding their way and the love they deserve. They're not just characters with how humane and believeable their characterisations are. It's the complexities and depiction of human emotions and their internal/external drive to behave that count. Dean, who is extroverted and playful, seemingly carefree and easygoing, but is very lonely and skeptical about love - so much that he doesn't see the worth in himself and constantly questioning his worth. The father issues; his "up until now I've sworn to myself that I'm content of loneliness - 'cus none of it was ever worth the risk" train of thoughts (yes, I'm quoting Paramore's The Only Exception because this song is so Dean-coded? Hello K'Prang and team is there any way that Dean character was inspired by this song?); Dean who is compromising his ownself just to never be alone; Dean who then denied his own feelings for Moth, his fear of hurting him, the horror in his eyes when he thinks he could hurt Moth the same way his father has hurt everyone. His self-worth issues. The constant fear of becoming a cheater like his father - despite never really committing to anyone. The lover; someone who longs for home and his own person to come home to. He might feel like he was ready for every storm when he first met Moth, but oh what did he even know about yearning for someone. I shed tears for him many times, despite the portrayal of being the reddest red flag in the series. William is insane for this. His facial expressions and especially eyes are so powerful in bringing such complex, multi-dimensional, humane Dean to life. The confusion, the emptiness, the denial, the longing - ah, what do we know about love except that it's about wanting and giving while also hurting ourselves in the process. Easily the best character ever portrayed by William so far.


Moth, my sassy princess, the feeler who thinks there's no need to feel if it means tearing the old scars apart. The one who thinks there'll be no rejection if you reject first, if you keep a comfortable distance; that there'll be no pain if you don't fall for the deception of love. But who is he to deny when all he needs is the love he deserves? It was exceptionally painful to see him asking Dean in the first episode if "he liked him" as a condition for them to "date", while also convincing himself over and over again that his relationship with Dean is not, and will never be serious. I can almost picture that there's a rope in his head tying him to not get attached, to not fall, all while he was falling so harder and harder (ep 5 Moth none of us can save you because you probably don't wanna be saved). Such a complicated character to portray and Est is doing God's work for it. I remember he said that he studied Moth by himself, without relying on other characters/people that might feel similar to him - and oh how excellent it is to see Moth alive in his hands. All sassy, most of the time confused, the vulnerability of wanting to be chosen and special. It's kind of like crazy to see this mixture of realistic characterisation and it's not really portrayed so often on screen. Following Moth's journey is like rediscovering my favourite songs about feelings that are too hard to convey and express in person. I remember one particular scene from ep4 when Moth was staring at Dean who was sleeping on his bed and immediately Niki's Tsunami came in ("A roaring tsunami, you came crashing in like an act of God - shake my earth, suck the air out, burn me down"; "I'm going under Storm, lightning, thunder, I'm drowning in the deepest of truths - Fuck, I think I'm falling for you"). And for the entirety of the series whenever he clearly wanted to be chosen, to be seen, to matter for Dean, there's Adore by Paramore ("If I let you love me, by the one adored, would you go all the way? Be the one I'm looking for"). For every scene in the nightclub when Dean and Moth seeks pleasure in the middle of the crowd, I can almost hear Clearest Blue by CHVRCHES playing in the background ("If ever I try to push away, you can just keep me, tell me - tell me, tell me you'll meet me, will you meet me more than halfway up?"). It's just extraordinary, because then I realised these characters are not merely one-dimensional, fictional tale, but rather a set of relatable stories and emotions whom I can refer to books I read and songs I listen to. The experience of following this series is honestly priceless. I'm just so happy to be here in real-time to witness how the story of these two maniacs unfold. I hope WilliamEst are proud of this work as I am, and I hope they keep on doing what they're doing - because to choose this story to include in their portfolio? Wow, they do have a knack.


Now, on how the series was executed and why not all people are ready to have the story presented through different formula. While I agree that this series is not perfect (well, no series are perfect in my own opinion actually), easily it has one of the best production. I particularly love how they choose to keep so many mundane and ordinary conversations flowing like everyday-life human interactions between Dean and Moth. The bantering, the little arguments and how they spice up the relationship are so important to me! They highlight how attraction doesn't grow in a vacuum. Are Dean and Moth both physically attractive? Yes. Is it enough for them to, at least, sexually attracted and infatuated with each other? Also yes. But often times we human beings need more depth to feel more than just attraction - and Dean and Moth successfully portray that through how they communicate and treat each other. Those soft gazes and caresses when the world is dark and quiet, warm embrace when the room feels too cold, when one cares so much to come stay by your side and be with you when you can't even let yourself cry out of sadness and grief, when it's just two of you letting your hearts bare to be taken care of. The chemistry is honestly off the roof. WilliamEst kiss like real couples do (not saying they're not real though - oops), and they're soo comfortable being in each other's personal space touching each other. None of those physical intimacies feel out of place to me - the first ones when they started getting infatuated with each other, as well as the lived-in touches when they're already so used to being with each other. You see, many series often have their default kind of "graph" in developing dynamics, and a lot of them come out like a pattern. We can almost predict when the characters fall in love, when they get together with each other, when they have sex, when they break up and when they come back together knowing they're made for each other. You Maniac refused to give in to this "trend" and create their own graph, which definitely sums up how it feels to have feelings for someone. Feelings sometimes don't align with logic. Dean and Moth may have been physically involved without any status, but who are we to judge why they don't just "easily" establish their relationship in a conventional way? Their red-flagness may come off from lack of openness, the fear of being seen as vulnerable, abandonment and self-worth issues, and full denial of wanting something real. It's crazy, and it's real, and it's describeable and I'm so glad that they manage to serve all these in 10 episodes.


I am so thankful to everyone involved in production of this series, I really am. It's definitely not easy working on this, especially when public opinions are mixed. I'm just gonna reiterate that this series is one of the best that could ever happened in the last few years, and although it deserves so much more appreciation and attention, this gotta count as a cult favourite (with me being the head of the cult probably). I'm so glad the director went with different route of the storytelling for this series, which definitely made it fresher and intriguing as it unfolded. While many people said we didn't get enough the scenes they needed (which, uhm, particularly emphasised on nc scenes and minor details - which is absolutely fine being cut off since the story still delivered), I'm so glad they managed to highlight the most important parts, beautiful details of DeanMoth's relationship: how to be vulnerable in front of someone you love, to show up in the lightest and darkest moments, to admit that the hearts want what they want, to let yourself love and be loved in return.


The scene of Dean begging with William's voice so hoarse, so desperate, while Moth was crying because he loves him too much and is torn between staying and pursuing his dreams - raw and beautiful. The confession and kiss scene under the bridge? Absolute cinema. That ending, shot from above as we leave DeanMoth kissing on their picnic mat? Ended me. So peak.


Easily 10/10 I've ever given. Viva la Bildungsroman!






Share this text on X


Views: 50